Following is a discussion I had recently with ChatGPT. While this experiment was just to explore the responses received for various ideas presented to the AI, it proved quite beneficial and sparked thoughts on more perspectives pertaining to this topic.
Ship of Theseus
The captain of the ship
What makes an object? The idea of it being an object or the parts that constitute it?
Is the functionality of an object its identity?
Identity: what changes and what exists indefinitely?
Essence
Like any philosophical question/paradox, Ship of Theseus doesn’t have one particular solution. It requires contemplation from various perspectives, surpassing both physical and metaphysical realms. However, like root of any philosophical discussion, it aims to relate to us humans, to our consciousness, life ,purpose and endless pursuit of truth.
Can you be the same “you” if you lost a body part(s), or if few of them are replaced with prosthetics?
Are you still “yourself” if your brain stopped functioning or lost all its memories?
Can a clone or a robot ever becoma a fully functional human if we had technologies to assemlble all the critical body parts & organs into it?
Finally, do you cease to be “you” without a soul?
If my essence is something no intelligence amongst us could ever reproduce (let’s presume), then mustn’t that essence of mine (my soul) have an origination from somewhere out of this realm?
Hope you liked this post and it prompted you to ponder some existential questions! If you have something to share/add on this or would like to talk about your views, feel free to write/comment!
Love to Read! 
Leave a comment